Afghanistan reports of torture and killing contradict Talibans promises

Evidence of Taliban killings, detentions and intimidation is emerging across Afghanistan, ominously contradicting the hardline Islamist group’s promise earlier this week not to take revenge against its opponents.

With reports of the Taliban going door to door searching for people who worked with the former Afghan government or western countries, claims have also emerged of Taliban fighters torturing and killing members of an ethnic minority in Afghanistan after overrunning their village last month.

Amnesty International said its researchers had spoken to witnesses in Ghazni province who recounted how the Taliban killed nine Hazara men in the village of Mundarakht between 4 and 6 July.

Hazaras are Shia Muslims who were previously persecuted by the Taliban and who made major gains in education and social status in recent years.

Agnès Callamard, the head of Amnesty International, said the brutality of the killings was “a reminder of the Taliban’s past record and a horrifying indicator of what Taliban rule may bring”.

The rights group said many more killings may have gone unreported because the Taliban cut mobile phone services in many areas they have captured to prevent images from being published.

03:33

In a separate incident, Taliban fighters killed a relative of an Afghan journalist working for the German broadcaster Deutsche Welle whom they were looking for in western Afghanistan. The broadcaster revealed that three more of its journalists had had their homes raided.

There have been reports of demonstrators being killed in several cities in recent days, and the beating and intimidation of those trying to flee the country, not least around the airport in Kabul.

Commenting on the Deutsche Welle case, Katja Gloger, of the German division of Reporters Without Borders, said: “Sadly, this confirms our worst fears. The brutal action of the Taliban shows that the lives of independent media workers in Afghanistan are in acute danger.”

Many Afghans fear a return to the Taliban’s harsh rule of the late 1990s, when the group largely confined women to their homes, banned television and music, chopped off the hands of suspected thieves and held public executions.

The concern was underscored by a report written by the RHIPTO Norwegian Center for Global Analyses, which provides information to the UN, that said militants were screening people on the way to Kabul airport.

The executive director of RHIPTO said the organisation knew about several threat letters sent to Afghans, including a man who was taken from his Kabul apartment this week by the Taliban.

“We had access to hard copies of concrete letters issued and stamped by the Taliban military commission to this effect,” said Christian Nellemann.

Joe Biden suggested on Thursday that between 50,000 and 65,000 Afghans might be at risk from the new regime, and western military leaders pledged to redouble their efforts to evacuate those desperate to escape. A Nato official disclosed that about 18,000 people had already been airlifted out.

In a sign of the new urgency, Germany said it would send two light helicopters to help evacuate citizens in the Kabul area after a German was shot and wounded driving to the airport.

However, most Afghans are unable to leave their homeland and those who may be in danger “have no clear way out”, the United Nations refugee agency said on Friday.

Shabia Mantoo, a spokesperson of the UN high commissioner for refugees (UNHCR), reiterated a call to neighbouring countries to keep their borders open to allow people to seek asylum, in light of what she called the “evolving crisis”.

The mounting concern over the pace of evacuations, and threat to those trying to flee, was addressed by Nato foreign ministers on Friday. During a virtual meeting, the ministers expressed concern over the “grave events” and called for “an immediate end to violence”, amid reports of “serious human rights violations and abuses across Afghanistan”.

Reuters reported that the US state department was expected to announce that its evacuation flights out of Kabul would now be able to land in Europe, because of an overflow of people in Qatar.

With thousands of people still thronging the airport, the Taliban urged unity before Friday prayers, calling on imams to persuade people not to leave Afghanistan.

Criticism of the pace and conduct of the evacuation has mounted in recent days amid images of the chaos and desperation, and evidence of the often arbitrary rules that have excluded large numbers of people who worked for western countries.

The Dutch foreign minister, Sigrid Kaag, said countries were struggling to track which evacuation flights their nationals were being put on. “Because of the chaos at the airport, we do not at this moment have a clear picture of in which airplane our own people are, or the citizens of other European countries or Nato allies, or of Afghan personnel â€" no country does,” Kaag said.

In a further blow to the credibility of the Biden administration, which claims it could not have predicted the speed of the collapse of Afghan government forces, the Wall Street Journal claimed a state department cable dated 13 July warned of rapid territorial gains by the Taliban and the subsequent collapse of Afghan security forces, and offered recommendations on ways to mitigate the crisis and speed up an evacuation.

In a more hopeful sign, the US state department spokesperson Ned Price said in Washington that 6,000 people were cleared for evacuation on Thursday and were expected to board military flights in the coming hours. That would mark a major increase from previous days.

Biden was due to speak about the evacuation efforts on Friday, having faced a torrent of criticism for his handling of the troop withdrawal negotiated by the previous Trump administration, not least the lack of planning of what was certain to be a huge rescue effort.

The Biden administration in particular is under pressure to expand the scope of its efforts after it was disclosed that some European forces, including an elite French police team, crossed Taliban lines and entered the city streets of Kabul to rescue civilians.

An official familiar with talks with the Taliban said the group did not plan to make any decisions or announcements about the new government until after the 31 August US withdrawal date passes.

The official said the Taliban’s lead negotiator, Anas Haqqani, had told his ex-government interlocutors that the insurgent movement had a deal with the US “to do nothing” until after the final withdrawal date.

Share this post